Evidence

Reviews that substantively treat this mechanism

2026-10-14 · Law, Regulation & Liability

ANCHOR Guidelines: A Constitutional Blueprint for Human-Centred Judicial AI in India

Keeping a human judge formally in charge does not by itself preserve judicial legitimacy; a governable judicial-AI regime must also make algorithmic influence, institutional operators, override incentives, and avenues for contestation independently auditable.

AuthorityAccountabilityContestabilityRedressDelegationAuditabilityInstitutional Capacity
2026-10-01 · AI Governance

Toward Web 4.0: bidirectional trust between AI agents and blockchain

Verifiable agent infrastructure can make identity, delegation, execution, and evidence machine-checkable without settling who is entitled to govern, whose preferences should count, or how affected parties can contest automated authority.

AuthorityDelegationLegitimacyAccountabilityDependency
2026-10-01 · AI Governance

JAZB Framework v1.1: Judiciary AI Zero-Trust Broker

JAZB makes machine authority governable by turning provenance, delegation, revocation, jurisdiction, actuation, and evidence into explicit control objects, but organizational authority becomes legitimate governance only when the human sovereign root is itself constrained, contestable, and externally accountable.

AuthorityDelegationRevocationEnforcementProvenanceAuditabilityInstitutional Capacity
2026-09-29 · Platform Governance & Internet Governance

The Agentic Web Requires New Normative Infrastructure

The paper successfully makes platform control over agent access a governance object, but its delegation-transparency-proportionality triad remains normative infrastructure in design form until access disputes have shared evidence, revocation, adjudication, and remedy.

AuthorityDelegationGatekeepingEnforcementContestability
2026-09-24 · AI Governance

When AI Begins to Build AI

The paper is strong on making control executable, but incomplete as governance: moving authority out of the agent does not solve the problem unless the control plane's own power to define, enforce, revoke, and contest policy is legitimate and constrained.

AuthorityLegitimacyRevocationDelegationEnforcementRedress
2026-09-16 · AI Governance

Designing Loyalty: AI Agents and Conflicts of Interest

A duty of loyalty becomes governable only when delegated authority, conflicts of interest, execution boundaries, revocation, and evidence of action can be made observable and enforceable at the point an agent acts.

AuthorityDelegationAccountability
2026-09-08 · AI Governance

AI Agents Push Humans Out of the Loop

Human oversight is not a governance control merely because a person remains in the loop; it is effective only while the system preserves the attention, expertise, independence, and decision capacity required to exercise authority over it.

AuthorityDelegationAccountability
2026-09-07 · Trust Infrastructure

Authority is a Continuous System

A continuity model can prevent downstream authority manufacture, but a governable system still needs explicit rules for how legitimate authority is created, revoked, disputed, and restarted.

AuthorityDelegationRevocationLegitimacy
2026-09-04 · Digital Identity

Designing Agent IDs

An agent ID can make identity, provenance, and permission legible to a service, but it becomes governance infrastructure only when the authority behind those claims can be scoped, refreshed, revoked, contested, and independently trusted.

AuthorityDelegationAccountabilityGatekeepingDependency
2026-08-03 · AI Governance

Critique of Agent Model

The paper correctly identifies that advanced agents redistribute control by internalising goals, identity, deliberation, and learning, but it mistakes architectural visibility for governability: an inspectable module is not an accountable institution unless authority, constraint, revocation, evidence, and redress are executable around it.

AuthorityDelegationAccountabilityContestabilityRevocationRedressEnforcement
Cross-paper knowledge

Findings connected to this theme

Cross-paper finding · 4 source reviews

Identity and provenance do not establish authority

Knowing who or what acted, or proving the causal origin of an action, does not establish that the actor was entitled to exercise the authority required for that action.

Reviews of agent IDs, provenance-bounded execution, credential verification and national trust infrastructure converge on a recurring category boundary between attribution and legitimate mandate.

AuthorityLegitimacyProvenanceDelegation
Evidence base
Cross-paper finding · 3 source reviews

Delegated authority is a lifecycle, not a grant event

A governed delegation must remain bounded, current, observable and revocable throughout execution rather than being treated as valid merely because an initial credential, token or policy grant existed.

The archive repeatedly finds that delegation proposals are more complete at issuance than at expiry, suspension, revocation, restoration, dispute and evidence preservation.

AuthorityDelegationRevocationRedress
Evidence base
  • Designing Agent IDs
    An agent ID can make identity, provenance, and permission legible to a service, but it becomes governance infrastructure only when the authority behind those claims can be scoped, refreshed, revoked, contested, and independently trusted.
  • Authority is a Continuous System
    A continuity model can prevent downstream authority manufacture, but a governable system still needs explicit rules for how legitimate authority is created, revoked, disputed, and restarted.
  • Designing Loyalty: AI Agents and Conflicts of Interest
    A duty of loyalty becomes governable only when delegated authority, conflicts of interest, execution boundaries, revocation, and evidence of action can be made observable and enforceable at the point an agent acts.
Cross-paper finding · 3 source reviews

Responsibility follows the topology of knowledge and control

In agentic systems, accountability cannot be assigned reliably from formal role labels or the presence of a human approver; it depends on who had relevant knowledge, intervention power and decision authority at the points where consequential pathways were created.

Recent reviews independently move accountability away from nominal human presence and toward the actual distribution of decision rights, oversight capacity and stop-work authority.

AccountabilityAuthorityInstitutional CapacityDelegation
Evidence base
Cross-paper finding · 3 source reviews

Rights and duties must survive delegation across agent ecosystems

Normative duties become operational only when they remain attached to delegated action across developers, deployers, platforms and agents through constraints, evidence, intervention rights and remedy.

Fiduciary, human-rights and responsibility analyses reach a shared institutional problem. Distributed technical execution can diffuse responsibility unless duties are made traceable and enforceable across organizational boundaries.

AccountabilityDelegationEnforcementRedress
Evidence base
Research agenda

Open gaps connected to this theme

Open governance gap · 4 source reviews

How are delegated powers revoked and contested after deployment?

Agent governance proposals increasingly define duties and delegated authority, but operational revocation, evidence preservation, correction, restoration and redress remain less specified than initial authorization.

A governance system that can grant authority but cannot reliably withdraw or contest it creates persistent decision rights without a complete lifecycle.

DelegationRevocationContestabilityRedress
Evidence base
Open governance gap · 2 source reviews

What makes the origin of delegated authority legitimate?

Provenance-bounded execution can prevent downstream authority expansion, but it does not establish who may create a new authority origin, under what evidence, or how competing, renewed or disputed origins are reconciled.

Continuity can prove that execution stayed within an origin while leaving the institutional legitimacy of that origin outside the model.

AuthorityLegitimacyDelegationRevocation
Evidence base
Connections

Material relationships among relevant reviews